The Ghosts We Carry

The pattern of surrender began early, long before Ramadi, before Special Forces selection, before the weight of adult consequence could fully register. It began in Pennsylvania, in elementary school wrestling matches where the boy first tasted the bitterness of his own capitulation. Small hands raised in defeat, eyes downcast, the sensation of something vital slipping away with each abandonment.

When North Dakota claimed him, football became the next casualty. The pads and helmet gathered dust in the corner of his bedroom while winter winds howled against windows. Each discarded pursuit left an invisible mark, a hairline fracture in something fundamental that wouldn't reveal its true damage until years later.

But it was basketball that taught him the most devastating lesson. The game had been everything—the perfect vessel for his athletic gifts, the rare arena where his body and mind worked in seamless harmony. On the court, the gangly North Dakota transplant transformed into something graceful, something whole. He could dunk as a six-foot freshman, his body understanding physics and momentum with an intuition that his mind would later try to intellectualize during sixteen-mile runs. The plyometrics that had served him then would haunt him later, the memory of what his body once knew, of potential left fallow.

The squeak of sneakers against polished hardwood, the perfect arc of a three-point shot, the camaraderie of the locker room—all surrendered without external pressure. His parents had watched this abdication with confusion and concern, yet held to their philosophy of allowing him to chart his own course, to learn through his own decisions. The freedom that other teenagers might have craved became for him a dangerous absence of boundaries.

"I wish they'd made it so quitting wasn't an option," he once admitted during a Thursday dinner with his parents, the rare confession slipping out between bites, hanging in the air like something radioactive. "But I also appreciate that you let me make my own mistakes."

His mother had looked at him with eyes that carried decades of worry. "We thought you needed to learn your own lessons. We couldn't have known which ones you'd take to heart."

What he had learned, in that critical period when character calcifies into permanent form, was that he could walk away. That commitment was negotiable. That when difficulty or boredom or fear arrived, retreat remained available. It was the wrong lesson, but it had set like concrete.

High school provided yet another stage for the familiar pattern. In those crucial formative years, when most accumulated credits and credentials for college applications, he accumulated absences and alcohol-soaked weekends. After attending Army basic training during the summer between his junior and senior years—a rare achievement that should have prophesied dedication—he returned to civilian student life with stunning disregard for its structures and requirements.

Classes became optional abstractions, hours better spent with BJ in parking lots or empty rec centers, planning the weekend's dissolution. Friday and Saturday nights devoted to the singular pursuit of blackout oblivion at whatever house lacked adequate parental supervision. The school's architecture of accountability—detentions, parent notifications, threatened suspensions—meant nothing compared to the perfect freedom of abandonment.

He was methodically dismantling his future with the same focus he would later apply to sixteen-mile runs, the same discipline he would bring to weight training. His pursuit of academic failure represented commitment of a perverse kind, dedication to dismantling rather than building. The administration watched his trajectory with grim certainty—another statistic forming in real time, another dropout preparing to happen.

Then came the unexpected intervention. His recruiter, SSG Roberson—a man who saw potential where others might have seen only delinquency—became the unlikely architect of completion. Not from any cynical motivation about meeting quotas, but from genuine concern for a young man veering toward self-destruction. The school board meeting where this Army representative made his case, speaking of capacities and promise that transcended the accumulated absences and disciplinary reports. And the board members listened—these educators from a rural district that encompassed nearly all of Nelson County but graduated just forty-five students each year. They knew him, had watched him grow, could see beyond his current rebellion to the possibilities that still existed.

The conversation wasn't about expedience but opportunity. Their agreement came not from indifference but from a collective recognition that traditional structures were failing this particular student, that an alternative path might better serve his specific needs. The hastily arranged competency tests, the bureaucratic exception that allowed him to graduate in April 2002, months before his classmates would cross the same stage—all manifestations of adults who genuinely cared, who recognized potential worth salvaging.

Another paradoxical moment in his pattern—escaping the commitment of school through the commitment to military service. What appeared like quitting was actually, in this rare instance, a form of continuance, enabled by people who saw more in him than his behavior suggested, who were willing to take chances on his behalf that he wouldn't take for himself. The diploma that would later enable his college applications, his government employment, his external markers of success—all because people intervened in the pattern, because they sensed something worth preserving beneath the self-sabotage.

From high school, the trajectory carried him to Fort Sill for training as an Army forward observer, then to Fort Stewart for active duty service. The adolescent who couldn't be bothered to attend morning classes somehow transformed into the soldier who rose before dawn, who maintained equipment with fastidious attention, who memorized radio procedures and artillery calculations with focused precision. The external structure imposed what internal discipline could not yet provide. But the pattern remained, dormant rather than defeated, waiting for circumstances that would allow its re-emergence.

Years later, in the Army, the pattern reemerged with consequences that extended beyond himself. After his first Iraq deployment, the temporary desertion—those weeks AWOL with his biological father in Pennsylvania—represented more than just military dereliction. It was his final connection with the man who had existed primarily as absence in his life, the man whose DNA had programmed both his physical gifts and the tendency toward escape that now defined him. The irony wasn't lost on him—his last act of connection with his father had been an act of disconnection from his duty. As if abandonment were the only language they truly shared.

This strange interlude had preceded his return, his reassignment to South Korea, and ultimately his second deployment to Ramadi—the crucible that would transform him in ways both profound and irreversible. But the pattern persisted, dormant but not defeated.

College had interrupted the cycle temporarily. The academic environment suited his analytical mind, offered challenges that engaged rather than depleted him. The combination of student loans and GI Bill benefits removed financial pressure, while his natural intellect made the coursework manageable. For once, perseverance required less effort than quitting, and so he stayed, collected his honors, wore the robes at graduation. The deviation from his pattern provided no inoculation against its return.

The National Guard experience after college contained both his greatest commitment and his most devastating surrender. The transformation had been total—abstention from alcohol, a training regimen that bordered on self-punishment, a focus that excluded all distractions. Those pre-dawn ruck marches from Tenleytown through Georgetown to Arlington and back to Union Station—bleeding feet in government office shoes, the physical pain a welcome distraction from deeper wounds. The Special Forces challenge weekends where he excelled so consistently that cadre invited him to instruct other candidates. The precious orders assigning him to an Operational Detachment, specifying his future as an 18E communications sergeant. The path so clear, so certain, so earned through sacrifice and discipline.

Then, incomprehensibly, surrender. Again.

On one of the final days of Selection, with success within grasp, he had simply... stopped. Walked away. Abandoned the culmination of years of preparation, the fulfillment of boyhood dreams of elite warrior status. The decision defied rational explanation, remained impenetrable even to himself. In his most honest moments, he recognized it as a fundamental betrayal of his own potential, a capitulation to some dark current that had always run beneath the surface of his achievements.

Read the Complete Manuscript

The immediate aftermath had unfolded with grim predictability. That first dark stout at Rock Bottom Brewery after years of abstinence, the perfect metaphoric venue for his psychological state. The craft beer blog that justified excess, the fifty bottles that never survived a weekend. The nightly drinking that somehow never interfered with professional advancement—his compartmentalization skills allowing him to maintain external competence while internal dissolution progressed unchecked.

His conventional National Guard unit had offered a second chance—Officer Candidate School selection representing potential redemption, a path back toward the man he believed he should have been. And once again, he had quit. Simply stopped showing up, disappeared from the brotherhood that represented his most sacred values. The eventual discharge papers formalized what he already knew—that he had failed not just the institution but himself, had defiled something he revered.

"Two years in Iraq. All of that training for Selection. Unlimited promise and dedication; all just thrown away during an episode of prolonged depression and utter despair." The words emerged during his darkest nights, a confession to empty rooms or sometimes to Roux, who listened without judgment, who accepted his fractured nature without requiring explanation.

The pattern had become the central organizing principle of his existence, more defining than any professional achievement, more persistent than any relationship. In his apartment, surrounded by evidence of his contradictions—the spartan furnishings, the utilitarian arrangements, the workspace stripped to bare essentials—the paradox remained unresolved. How could someone so capable of sustained effort in running, in weight training, in intellectual pursuits, be simultaneously defined by these critical moments of surrender?

Every workout became both penance and reminder. Each rep, each mile, each bead of sweat represented atonement that could never be complete. While living in San Diego, his nightly walks along Imperial Beach had become exercises in self-flagellation, watching black helicopters deliver SEAL teams to Coronado training grounds, his mind repeating its merciless mantra: That should be you. You aren't good enough to be them. You quit.

At forty-one, the regret had metabolized into something almost physical—a presence that occupied his chest, that shaped his posture, that influenced every decision and non-decision. More than love, more than ambition, more than curiosity or fear or desire, regret drove him forward, propelled him through each methodical day, each sleepless night. The emotion had become so familiar that he could no longer imagine existence without it, could no longer conceive of a self not defined by what might have been.

In the gym mirror, between sets, he sometimes caught glimpses of alternative versions of himself—the operator he could have been, the officer he might have become, the man who held fast when others broke. These ghosts maintained perfect form, never faltered under weight, never surrendered to fatigue. They watched him with expressions not of judgment but of patient expectation, as if waiting for him to finally recognize what they had always known—that the capacity for completion existed within him, that the pattern could be broken, that surrender was a choice rather than destiny.

His body, despite the injuries and the years, remained capable of extraordinary endurance. Sixteen miles every other morning, weights pushed to the edge of safety, discipline that younger men envied from a distance. The physical vessel had never been the limitation. The betrayal had always come from elsewhere—from some mysterious circuit in his mind that tripped at critical moments, that transformed determination into surrender through alchemy he couldn't comprehend.

Perhaps this was why running provided such relief—because for those miles, the circuitry remained intact. The simple act of continuing, of placing one foot before the other regardless of discomfort, represented a temporary victory over the pattern. Each completed run, each full workout, each project carried through to conclusion accumulated as evidence against the defining narrative of surrender. Small completions that could never compensate for the significant abandonments, but that kept alive the possibility that the pattern was not immutable, that different choices remained available.

In his most private thoughts, in those pre-dawn hours when sleep evaded him and the racing mind ran its endless circuits, he nurtured a fragile hope. That the next challenge, the next opportunity, the next moment of decision might play out differently. That the pattern, however deeply inscribed, was not inescapable. That surrender, however familiar, was not inevitable. That completion, however elusive, remained possible.

This possibility, however remote, justified continued effort. It explained the predawn runs, the meticulous tracking of progress, the constant seeking of new physical and intellectual challenges. Not the expectation of redemption—he had lived too long to indulge such fantasies—but the refusal to accept the pattern as definitive, as complete, as the final word on who he was and what he might yet become.

The ghosts followed him, as they always did—Kuhns and Kinslow, the brothers lost in Ramadi, the potential selves abandoned along the way. But now they were joined by other presences, other possibilities—the runner who finished every race, the fighter who never conceded, the man who recognized commitment as non-negotiable. These alternatives existed not as rebukes but as reminders that history, however determining, was not destiny, that patterns, however established, contained within themselves the possibility of variation.

His life had been shaped by surrender, defined by critical moments of abandonment. But it was not yet complete. The story remained unfinished, the pattern not yet closed. Within this incompleteness resided both his deepest regret and his most stubborn hope—that his past need not determine his future, that the boy who mastered quitting might still become the man who masters endurance.